Slice of pumpkin ice cream pie with whipped cream and warm maple sauce
|

Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie with Warm Maple Sauce

This pumpkin ice cream pie stacks a flaky crust, a thick layer of vanilla ice cream and a fluffy spiced pumpkin cream, then finishes with whipped cream and warm maple sauce poured over each slice. It’s a frozen dessert, so it’s made days ahead and waits in the freezer until you need it.

The idea comes from upstate New York, where a pumpkin ice cream pie was the signature dessert at a family restaurant in Niagara Falls for more than fifty years. People still talk about it long after the restaurant closed. Our version keeps the layers that made it famous and adds two small tricks: a thin chocolate seal that keeps the crust crisp, and pumpkin that’s cooked down first for deeper flavor.

Jump to the recipe

What makes this pumpkin ice cream pie different

A classic baked pumpkin pie is a custard: eggs, milk and pumpkin set in the oven. This pie never goes in the oven after the crust is baked. The pumpkin layer is lightened with whipped cream instead of eggs, so it eats like a cold mousse, smooth and almost creme brulee-like, sitting on top of a slab of ice cream. When the warm maple sauce hits the cold pie, you get warm and cold, crisp and creamy in the same bite.

  • No soggy crust. A thin brush of melted chocolate acts as a barrier between the crust and the ice cream.
  • Real pumpkin flavor. Cooking canned pumpkin for a few minutes drives off water and concentrates the taste, so the layer doesn’t freeze icy.
  • Bloomed spices. The spices go into the hot pumpkin for the last few seconds, which makes them smell and taste stronger.
  • Stress-free hosting. It keeps in the freezer for days, so the dessert is done before the holiday cooking starts.

Ingredients for pumpkin ice cream pie

You need a baked 9-inch deep-dish pie crust, a little semisweet chocolate, a quart of vanilla ice cream, a can of pumpkin puree, brown sugar, warm spices, heavy cream for the filling and the topping, and pure maple syrup with butter for the sauce. Exact amounts are in the recipe card below.

Ingredient notes

  • Pie crust: use your favorite homemade crust, blind baked until golden, or a store-bought deep-dish shell. Many refrigerated and frozen crusts contain lard, so read the label if you avoid it. A graham cracker crust also works and is even easier.
  • Ice cream: a good vanilla bean ice cream is classic. Some cheaper brands use gelatin as a stabilizer, so check the ingredient list. Cinnamon or butter pecan ice cream is a fun swap.
  • Pumpkin: buy plain pumpkin puree, not pumpkin pie filling, which already has sugar and spices in it.
  • Spices: cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg and a pinch of cloves. You can use 2 teaspoons of our homemade pumpkin pie spice instead.
  • Vanilla: we use alcohol-free vanilla in the whipped cream.
  • Maple syrup: use pure maple syrup, not pancake syrup. It thickens a little as it warms with the butter.
Ingredients for pumpkin ice cream pie including pumpkin puree, ice cream and maple syrup

How to make pumpkin ice cream pie

1. Seal the crust with chocolate. Melt the chocolate gently, then brush a very thin layer over the bottom and sides of the baked, cooled crust. Freeze it for 10 minutes so the chocolate hardens into a shell.

2. Spread the ice cream. Let the ice cream sit on the counter for about 10 minutes, just until it’s scoopable. Scoop it into the crust and spread it evenly, pressing it against the chocolate without packing it down. Hold the crust with one hand as you spread, since a baked crust can shift in the pan. Freeze for 45 minutes.

Vanilla ice cream spread into a chocolate-sealed crust for pumpkin ice cream pie

3. Cook down the pumpkin. Put the pumpkin puree in a skillet over medium-low heat. Stir and scrape the bottom often for 7 to 8 minutes. You’ll see steam, the color will darken, and it will shrink by about a third. When it starts to sound dry, stir in the spices and cook 15 seconds more. Scrape it into a bowl, stir in the brown sugar and salt, and let it stand 5 minutes until the sugar melts and the mixture looks glossy. Spread it thin and refrigerate until fully cold, about 1 hour.

4. Whip and fold. Whip the cold heavy cream to stiff peaks. Stir about a third of it into the cold pumpkin to loosen it, then fold in the rest with a spatula, going around the bowl and up through the middle, until there are no white streaks.

Folding whipped cream into spiced pumpkin for pumpkin ice cream pie filling

5. Layer and freeze. Spoon the pumpkin cream over the ice cream in a few big dollops and spread it out, leaving a gentle mound in the center so every slice shows tall layers. Cover and freeze for at least 4 hours, or up to 3 days.

6. Finish and serve. Whip the topping cream with the powdered sugar and vanilla. Warm the maple syrup, butter and salt in a small pan for about 2 minutes. Let the pie stand 10 minutes, then slice with a sharp knife dipped in hot water and wiped dry. Press gently so the crust doesn’t crack. Top each slice with whipped cream, a drizzle of warm maple sauce and toasted pecans.

Tips for the best frozen pumpkin pie

  • Don’t skip chilling the pumpkin. Warm pumpkin will melt the whipped cream and the filling will deflate. It must be cold to the touch.
  • Watch the pan. Once the pumpkin starts to sound dry, it can scorch quickly. Keep stirring and lower the heat if it sputters.
  • Fold, don’t stir. Gentle folding keeps the air in the cream, which is what makes the pumpkin layer light instead of dense.
  • Use a deep-dish pan. A standard 9-inch pie plate won’t hold both layers. If yours is shallow, use about 3 cups of ice cream.
  • Warm the sauce, not the pie. Serve the maple sauce warm, but add it at the table so the layers stay sharp.

Variations

  • Gingersnap crust: mix 1 1/2 cups gingersnap crumbs with 5 tablespoons melted butter, press into the pan and bake 8 minutes at 350°F.
  • Caramel instead of maple: drizzle with the salted caramel from our no-bake salted caramel cheesecake.
  • Pecan crunch: sprinkle a handful of chopped toasted pecans over the ice cream before adding the pumpkin layer.

Make ahead and storage

This pumpkin ice cream pie is made to be prepared ahead. Once it’s frozen solid, wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and foil and keep it in the freezer for up to 2 weeks. Whip the topping and warm the sauce the day you serve it. Keep the leftover whipped cream in the fridge and use it within 2 days, and don’t leave cream-based desserts out for more than 2 hours, following FoodSafety.gov’s cold storage chart. Return any leftover pie to the freezer right after slicing.

More make-ahead holiday desserts

Planning a dessert table? Pair this pie with a classic pecan pie or a tray of pumpkin cheesecake bars. For more dishes you can finish days before the big meal, see our make-ahead holiday sides and desserts.

Pumpkin ice cream pie FAQ

How long does pumpkin ice cream pie need to freeze?

At least 4 hours after adding the pumpkin layer, plus 45 minutes for the ice cream layer before that. Overnight is easiest.

Can I make it without cooking the pumpkin?

Yes. Just stir the spices, sugar and salt into the puree and chill it. The pie will taste milder and the pumpkin layer can be a little icier, because it holds more water.

Why is the chocolate layer there?

It keeps moisture from the ice cream out of the crust, so the crust stays crisp in the freezer. It also adds a little surprise when you cut into the pie.

How do I cut a frozen pie cleanly?

Let it stand on the counter for 10 to 15 minutes, then use a long sharp knife dipped in hot water and wiped dry between cuts. Press straight down instead of sawing.

Can I use store-bought whipped topping?

You can use a tub of whipped topping for the pumpkin layer, about 2 cups, but freshly whipped heavy cream tastes richer and freezes creamier. Some whipped toppings contain gelatin-based ingredients, so check the label.

What ice cream flavor works best?

Vanilla is the classic choice and lets the pumpkin shine. Cinnamon, butter pecan or dulce de leche ice cream are all great swaps.

If you make this pumpkin ice cream pie, leave a comment and a star rating below. Maple sauce or caramel?

Slice of pumpkin ice cream pie with whipped cream and warm maple sauce

Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie with Warm Maple Sauce

A frozen pumpkin ice cream pie with a chocolate-sealed crust, a thick layer of vanilla ice cream, a fluffy spiced pumpkin cream layer, whipped cream and warm maple sauce. Make it up to 3 days ahead.
Prep Time 40 minutes
Cook Time 10 minutes
Freeze 5 hours
Total Time 5 hours 50 minutes
Servings: 10 slices
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Calories: 540

Ingredients
  

Crust and chocolate seal
  • 1 9-inch deep-dish pie crust fully baked and cooled (check store-bought labels for lard)
  • 2 oz semisweet chocolate chopped
Ice cream layer
  • 1 quart vanilla ice cream gelatin-free, softened 10 minutes
Spiced pumpkin cream
  • 1 (15 oz) can pumpkin puree not pumpkin pie filling
  • 1 tsp ground cinnamon
  • 1/2 tsp ground ginger
  • 1/4 tsp ground nutmeg
  • 1/8 tsp ground cloves
  • 1/2 cup light brown sugar packed
  • 1/4 tsp salt
  • 1 cup cold heavy cream
Whipped cream topping
  • 1 cup cold heavy cream
  • 3 tbsp powdered sugar
  • 1/2 tsp alcohol-free vanilla
Warm maple sauce
  • 1/2 cup pure maple syrup
  • 2 tbsp butter
  • 1 pinch salt
  • 1/3 cup toasted pecans chopped, optional

Method
 

  1. Seal the crust: melt the chocolate over low heat or in the microwave in 20-second bursts. Brush a thin layer over the bottom and sides of the baked crust. Freeze for 10 minutes until the chocolate is firm.
  2. Add the ice cream: let the ice cream soften on the counter for about 10 minutes. Scoop it into the crust and gently spread it into an even layer, pushing it against the chocolate. Freeze for 45 minutes.
    Vanilla ice cream spread into a chocolate-sealed crust for pumpkin ice cream pie
  3. Cook down the pumpkin: cook the pumpkin puree in a skillet over medium-low heat, stirring often, for 7 to 8 minutes until it darkens and thickens and loses about a third of its volume. Stir in the cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg and cloves and cook 15 seconds more. Transfer to a bowl, stir in the brown sugar and salt, spread thin and refrigerate until completely cold, about 1 hour.
  4. Whip and fold: whip 1 cup cold heavy cream to stiff peaks. Stir one third into the cold pumpkin to loosen it, then gently fold in the rest until no streaks remain.
    Folding whipped cream into spiced pumpkin for pumpkin ice cream pie filling
  5. Top and freeze: spread the pumpkin cream over the ice cream layer, leaving a slight mound in the center. Cover and freeze for at least 4 hours or up to 3 days.
  6. Finish and serve: whip the topping cream with the powdered sugar and vanilla to soft peaks. Warm the maple syrup with the butter and salt for 2 minutes. Let the pie sit out 10 minutes, slice with a knife dipped in hot water, top with whipped cream, drizzle with warm maple sauce and sprinkle with pecans.

Notes

Make ahead: the pie keeps in the freezer, well wrapped, for up to 2 weeks. Add the whipped cream and maple sauce just before serving. Check that your ice cream and store-bought crust are gelatin-free and lard-free if that matters to you.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating